Will people stop making music if AI becomes superior in music making?

And the Grammy goes to Robot AI 324XHD.

3 Likes

Yeah I totally agree. People don’t realize all that “ambient techno”, “study music”, “soft jazz for sleep” etc. are in danger. You can already buy sample packs and create something similar incredibly fast. Imagine a software digests millions of these songs which are not super different from each other. I can totally see it’s producing a full hour mix with what’s been trained with.

Similarly i think if an artist produces only one type of genre or very similar music, that’s in danger too. Because you will just hit the button “create a 128BPM track in the style of X” and you will probably get a very decent starting point.

This one has been around for years, and can generate continuous streams.

1 Like

In that Sam Altman interview by Lex Friedman they discuss how humans being interested in what other humans are doing seems inherently built in.
They discuss it as if it’s something that will not ever go away.
I thought that was an interesting observation.

3 Likes

In the Capital City, sons and daughters of the elites will be allowed to practice traditional music under close AI control.

The remaining workers in the districts are strictly forbidden from all forms of art and personal expression. For the good of humanity your brothers and sisters urge you to sow the fields proudly.

Dissent will result in societal termination.

/subrout/#162727-fgh/pop_cntl;ALPHA/&/&:?:$//enable

5 Likes

:smile:

been there done that, nah I’m out ya’ll can have that :rofl:

1 Like

shit i didn’t catch lol… I’m watching youuu Rob Lowe

1 Like

Why should I stop making what I love, something that gives me joy. Even today 99,9% of the other musicians are better than me but I still love making beats. Actually the more I think about it, I come to the conclusion that AI in a lot of regards has the potential to free human creativity from commercial shackles. Maybe art will become something truly personal and more private. Something that takes place in small communities like here or local.
Making music is like writing diary to me. First of all it is for me. It should be important to me. It should be worth to be recorded or performed whatever to me. And if other people can find something of interest in it this is even better

2 Likes

Poetry

1 Like

I’m sure it’ll churn out a bunch of crap, and maybe some weird soundscape installation. But that’s it.

1 Like

A study by German Gema and French Sacem, both PROs:
https://www.gema.de/documents/d/guest/gema-sacem-goldmedia-ai-and-music-pdf

Here below some excerpts:

AI is the next investment bubble to bust

We get a multi-billion dollar scam from Silicon Valley at least once a decade (probably more frequently)

AI can’t do what they claim and they don’t have the resources to sustain it in the meantime (the irony of hearing “we will replace humans” by a ruling class built on slave labor escapes no one)

This doesn’t mean it won’t wreak havoc. It always does

2 Likes

Stevie wonder is superior to me in music making, but I still get up and do it everyday.

6 Likes

AI has been depressing the hell out of me lately. I think the tech bro narrative of “if you don’t let us fuck up the world, some other country will beat us to it” is part of it.

I just finished reading A Canticle for Leibowitz (an inspiration for the Fallout game). It’s about mankind repeatedly nuking itself, but this line about a child that knows what a loaded pistol does but has never pulled the trigger before struck a chord.

7 Likes

The direction we’re headed, AI taking over music is the least of our worries. It’s also not the AI, it’s the ‘man behind the curtain’ we should be concerned about.

W/ that said, nothing will replace the feeling of making music, strumming a guitar, singing, and playing w/ other humans.

2 Likes

until we figure out how to create consciousness, music generated by AI will be polarizing like it has with visual art. it’ll be a couple decades or so

i look forward to submitting to our computer overlords

just kidding, the energy crisis is going to reach critical, there will be a devastating global war, and everything’s gonna be drastically scaled back under tight laws that will be part of something resembling a religion

hope so anyway

1 Like

I really, really didn’t like A Canticle for Leibowitz, but it has a few masterful passages, and this is one of them.

(The way Miller portrays the passage of time through bird migrations being the othe parts I loved.)

1 Like

Yeah, I had more or less the same feelings. Not a fun read, but there were a handful of spots that made me ponder things, so I’m glad I stuck it out. I had tried on a couple of other occasions.

1 Like

I really want to read War and Peace by Leo Tolstoy because I don’t think there’s anything human about the way people make war, it goes on endlessly behind the curtain, a real war, however cruel, ends with a battle like in the animal kingdom, but people have taken it to another level.

Call me negative. But those who are suffering usually didn’t A start the war and B are suffering because of it. Just my 2cents.

And Universal is licensing more music than they are publishing, there was a time when they really helped artists to break through, now they just register music because they have found it makes more profit. I think the people who make music independently are still in the majority anyways.